2015 Season
- Week 1: Carlos Hyde – San Juan Bananas
- Week 2: Larry Fitzgerald – Fear Boners
- Week 3: AJ Green – Deadly Nagintas
- Week 4: Devonta Freeman – Tom Selleck’s Moustache
- Week 5: Doug Martin – What Does John Fox Say
- Week 6: Devonta Freeman – Tom Selleck’s Moustache
- Week 7: Lamar Miller – Tom Selleck’s Moustache
- Week 8: Drew Brees – Deadly Nagintas
- Week 9: Antonio Brown – Chalupa Batman
- Week 10: Antonio Brown – Chalupa Batman
- Week 11: Thomas Rawls – Greg Schiano is an Idiot
- Week 12: Doug Baldwin – San Juan Bananas
- Week 13: Allen Robinson – Long Snappers
2014 Season
- Week 1: Julius Thomas – Long Snappers
- Week 2: Jordy Nelson – Rex in the City
- Week 3: Julio Jones – Chalupa Batman
- Week 4: Jamaal Charles – San Juan Bananas
- Week 5: Demaryius Thomas – Knuckle Ballers
- Week 6: Cam Newton – Fear Boners
- Week 7: Russell Wilson – Chalupa Batman
- Week 8: Ben Roethlisberger – What Does John Fox Say
- Week 9: Ben Roethlisberger – What Does John Fox Say
- Week 10: Marshawn Lynch – Chalupa Batman
- Week 11: Mike Evans – Deadly Nagintas
- Week 12: Justin Forsett – Deadly Nagintas
- Week 13: DeAndre Hopkins – Deadly Nagintas